Subtle Body Experience after Death

Question:  Some time ago, there was a plane crash. The pilot was depressed and wanted to kill himself and all the other people on the plane as well.  All these people died together and lost their gross material bodies. Can the jivas in subtle bodies see each other?  Do they have rational faculties to understand the situation of how they got killed?  Can they experience emotions like hatred or vengeance for the pilot, and will this cause them to get even with him in some future life?  

Answer: First of all, when you die, you are not free to think and do whatever you want.  You come under the control of the Lord of death, Yamarāja. By the laws of karma, it will be decided where you will go next.  It is not that you can sit down and brood over how you died and how this guy did this or that.  Before you died, if you knew that he was going to do this and you were angry as a result, you will then carry that anger with you and that will become instrumental in your next birth, and in that way, your consciousness will manifest in that birth. When you die, you are not conscious of the external world, just like when you go to sleep, you forget everything and go into a different state of mind. These people died suddenly, not knowing why the crash happened. Therefore, there is no question of having feelings of vengeance towards the pilot. However, if he had announced that he was going to kill them all, they would have felt angry and fearful and would have carried that emotion into their next life. Otherwise, the only thing they know is that they are dying because of a plane crash and they may carry that fear of fire and crash into their next lives. They may have a phobia of flying, of fire, or have claustrophobia in their next lives. 

Question:  Can they see each other when they are in the subtle body?

Answer: The jivas in subtle bodies don’t see each other.  They cannot see unless they get another form, such as that of a ghost.  The subtle body by itself cannot see unless it inhabits another type of body. There are various types of bodies that are subtle in comparison with the gross body. The subtle body refers to the psychic body which consists of the mind, intelligence, ego, citta (sometimes translated as heart or unconscious mind), the senses and the five vital energies. The subtle body, however, needs another body with sense organs, through which the internal and external senses can function. 

Question: But a ghost does not have a gross body, and so has no sense organs. How does the subtle body function in it?

Answer:  The subtle body is like the basic template which is covered by another body. There are various types of bodies, such as deva, yakṣa, rākṣasa, gandharva, kinnara etc.

Question:  Does it mean that after death, either the Yamadūtas or Viṣṇudūtas, take the template to another body?

Answer: Yes, one is given another body. If one is transported to the spiritual world, one is given a spiritual body. If one has to suffer in hell, one is given a yātanā śarīra, a body for suffering, and if one goes to heaven, one is given a heavenly body according to their good karma. The yātanā śarīras and heavenly bodies are of various types, just like here on earth, there are various types of bodies. 

Question:  If one has to take birth again, does one have to wait for a special period of time? 

Answer:  Sooner or later everyone has to take birth on earth, which is called the planet of death, martya loka. One has to return to human birth because it is only in human life that one can acquire new karma. This may take some time and can vary from person to person. One can remain even inside a seed, such as grain, and lie there for a long time. 

Question: During that time, is the jīva practically unconscious?

Answer: Yes, you remain in that unconscious state without a gross body.

Question:  How is that unconscious state different from the liberated stage?

Answer:  This unconscious state is under the influence of tamas or ignorance. The ātmā is not aware of its state. It is complete ignorance, like in deep sleep.

Question: How long does this last?

Answer:  It can take yugas! That is why this human form is so rare and if we realize its importance, we will not waste our time in useless activities, such as endeavouring for material pleasures, being envious of others, making plans to take revenge, sitting and gossiping and criticizing others, reading mundane literature or watching mundane shows and movies. Most people fritter away their precious human life, and do not get anything substantial.  

Notify me of new articles

Comments ( 5 )
  1. Kurt W Shoemaker

    I have a few follow up questions. If the JIVA without body has no conscious state like deep sleep, then does the JIVA even have a complete awareness of time in that state? If several Yugas pass, would the JIVA in this state even realize this? Is the awareness of the passage of time different for animals and humans? Are humans more aware of time passing than other earthly bound forms? Thanks in advance fo any elaboration on this.

    • Babaji Post author

      ” I have a few follow up questions. If the JIVA without body has no conscious state like deep sleep, then does the JIVA even have a complete awareness of time in that state?”

      The concept of time is in the mind. If the mind is not active or becomes absorbed, you lose the concept of time.

      “If several Yugas pass, would the JIVA in this state even realize this?”


      “Is the awareness of the passage of time different for animals and humans?”


      “Are humans more aware of time passing than other earthly bound forms?”

      Yes, even one human being has different feelings of time than another. In suffering, time seems to elongate, and in happiness, it seems to contract.
      The gopis say that in separation, a moment appears like a kalpa and in union with Krsna a kalpa appears like a moment.

  2. Vraja Kishor

    I’m curious… the common description I here is “A ghost is a subtle body without a physical body” – but after reading this I think maybe a “bhūta” is an actual species of life, and thus they do have some akāśa body or something like that. Could you shed any light on this curiosity?

    • Malatimanjari Post author

      Yes, you are right. There is bhuta-yoni, or a species of ghosts. In fact, there are different varieties in them – bhuta, preta, piśāca, dākini, śakini, brahma-rākṣasa. etc.

  3. My name is Dr.Abhijit Dam & I am a palliative care physician with an interest in death, dying & afterlife. I have written a book called ‘Mrtyu’ based on my experiences with dying & afterlife. While writinf the chapter on the fate of the sukshma & Karana sharira after death, I was actually unaware of what I was writing…as if I was being guided by an external force…when later, I reviewed the script, I was surprised as to where the information came from….

  • Satyanarayana Dasa

    Satyanarayana Dasa
  • Daily Bhakti Byte

    You can offer anything to Krishna, but you have to offer it with love. You have to offer it with some awareness. You really have to offer it from your heart. Don’t just offer it mechanically. Even if you have some bad habit, offer it to God. Because eventually your consciousness will change and you will think, why am I doing this to God?

    — Babaji Satyanarayana Dasa
  • Payment

    If you want to donate to Jiva Institute, please contact
  • Subscribe

  • Article Archive

  • Chronological Archive

© 2017 JIVA.ORG. All rights reserved.