Question: How detrimental is the regular association of non-devotees (in terms of family, and business associates)? And what is to be done about it?
Answer: It is not detrimental if you are fixed in your goal of devotion to God, rather you will influence them.
Question: Is the aim to stop material enjoyment entirely, or to stop certain forms of material enjoyment, or is all material enjoyment equal if performed in devotion. Or do some forms of enjoyment, even if taken in devotion, retain their negative effects?
Answer: Any nondevotional enjoyment is detrimental.
Question: Why did Caitanya Mahapabhu change/invert the maha mantra?
Answer: He did not. In Sanat Kumar Samhita the Maha Mantra is mentioned in the order which Lord Chaitanya gave. In the Kaliysantarana Upanishad it is mentioned in the revers order, so both are valid.
Purusha and conception
Question: I read how the male element is Purusa and Female is Prakriti in Ayurveda. Does this mean that the sperm contains purusa and the female egg does not? This would make sense since the sperm has mobility and the egg does not. Does the sperm carry the purusha with it during conception?
Answer: Both sperm and egg have life. When they combine then the purusha enters them. So in a way the sperm acts as a purusha because it attracts the purusha.
Question: I also recall reading in Bhagavatam that from the Lord’s Genitals originate water, semen, rains and procreation. Would this mean that when male seed is spilled with intent and without conception it is a form of violence to the sperm itself by not allowing it to perform its natural function?
Question: By abstaining, does one derive any benefit from this and how so?
Answer: Yes, it benefits because you are not wasting your energy unnecessarily and you are gaining control over your senses. But it should not be repression.
Jiva Gosvami’s Knowledge
Question: I read in the introduction of your translation of Jiva Gosvami’s Bhakti Sandarbha (which I am thoroughly engulfed in) that Jiva Gosvami and his associates were practicing ”Causeless Love” and their writings simply put this practice into Vedantic and Upanisadic language. This means that Jiva Gosvami’s writings do not ORIGINATE from the Vedas. So where did Jiva Gosvamis knowledge originate from?
Answer: From Srimad Bhagavat Purana.
The Vedas are beginningless. Just as God is without a beginning, then his knowledge is also without a beginning. It may be revealed at a certain point in time to a specific person, but that does not mean that the Veda did not exist before. God’s knowledge is eternal because it’s God’s knowledge. The attributes of an eternal object are also eternal. That is why we are also eternal. We also have no beginning. The soul is not created because it is one of the potencies of God.
© 2017 JIVA.ORG. All rights reserved.